Credit: Shutterstock
Credit: Shutterstock

Is bootstrapping the most destructive American startup fantasy?

Stories of entrepreneurs, coming from humble beginnings and building their businesses from scratch, is an inspiration for many immigrant founders. However, not all of them are real, warns lifelong entrepreneur and mentor Michael Burtov. The ultimate American dream might be just a fantasy for those dreamers coming to the land of opportunity with no capital or connections.

Throughout my startup journey, I’ve consistently heard experts praise the value of bootstrapping a startup. The startup landscape is saturated with countless inspirational quotes and headlines, such as “6 Quotes on business & personal finance from a bootstrapped-to-$100M-valuation founder,” from the now-rightfully-defunct Silicon Valley Bank’s “Wealth Insights” section. 

This fantasy is perpetuated so frequently that many founders assume it’s the de facto startup approach.

The term “bootstrapping” originates from the old American expression of “pulling yourself up by your bootstraps,” which encourages individuals to rely on their resources, perseverance, personal sacrifice, and determination to rise from poverty to prosperity. However, in reality, this notion is absurd, unreasonable, and fosters disdain for those who lack resources.

In the business world, “bootstrapping” refers to an entrepreneur establishing a company with minimal capital, primarily relying on personal finances or the new company’s revenue. In the U.S., many wealthy “self-made” individuals adopt this origin story, often neglecting to mention the significant advantages they enjoyed, such as wealthy parents, government subsidies, connections, societal privileges, and access to quality education.

For instance, Elon Musk, once the world’s wealthiest man, frequently recounts his humble beginnings, working and sleeping in an office. However, he rarely mentions his privileged upbringing, successful parents, or his family’s ownership of an emerald mine in apartheid-era South Africa. Musk’s companies, Tesla and SpaceX, have also greatly benefited from government assistance, receiving over $7 billion in contracts and billions more in tax breaks, loans, and subsidies.

This bootstrapping myth is not limited to entrepreneurs in the U.S. Politicians, celebrities, and others in the public eye have crafted their own “rags-to-riches” stories, effectively taking all credit for their accomplishments and ignoring their family, community, privileges, and resources. 

It would certainly be odd for an entrepreneur to admit the truth and state that: “My success stemmed from a million-dollar investment from my father and my families’ connections to influential people who invested, introduced me to other influential people, and bought my products.” Instead, the prevailing narrative is: “I started with nothing, and now I am successful.”

The bootstrapping narrative, which is promoted by one of the most racially inequitable industries in the world, Venture Capital (where Black entrepreneurs receive less than 2% of all VC dollars each year), is at odds with Martin Luther King Jr’s observation that “It’s all right to tell a man to lift himself by his own bootstraps, but it is cruel to say to a bootless man that he ought to lift himself by his own bootstraps.”

Much like some of us might hesitate to upgrade our McDonald’s meal to a Large while others are concerned about the artisan brioche bun on their Wagyu beef burger, the concept of not being aware of privilege extends well beyond wealth to race and gender.

The American mythology of “rising up from nothing,” defying all odds and becoming successful, is deeply ingrained in the fabric of the nation, alongside apple pie, guns, and overpriced healthcare.

As an immigrant founder, most likely you aren’t wealthy, connected, or white, thereby making you a personification of the flaws in the bootstrapping myth of the U.S. startup world. This myth of “hard work leads to success” is one of the most dangerous American myths and a major factor in funding disparities in the U.S.

Many of us know people who work tirelessly from 5 a.m. to 11 p.m., cooking, cleaning, building and otherwise providing the foundation for our comfortable lives. They work hard but aren’t as nearly as successful as Elon Musk, who spends his days boasting about his humility on Twitter.

For immigrant founders who are surprised to learn that every successful individual they meet has risen from near-poverty through hard work, keep in mind that this narrative is a fantasy, internalized and believed by many, but a fantasy nonetheless. 

It’s a harmful fantasy that tears at the fabric of innovation in the U.S. However, if you want to better understand the American mindset, you can pretend that everything you accomplished in your life is entirely your own doing. And if you want to have productive conversations with venture capitalist-types, you can tell them as much.

But always remember this: when people advocate for bootstrapping as the universal starting point, they’re effectively saying that rich, privileged individuals deserve to be successful, while those who lack resources or connections do not.

About the author

Michael Burtov is a serial venture-backed entrepreneur who has grown multiple startups from initial ideas to millions in revenue and venture funding. He has appeared on Shark Tank and his work has been covered in hundreds of major media outlets. He is also the subject of mini-documentaries by Discovery Channel and CNN’s “Great Big Story.” Additionally, Michael has worked with hundreds of high-growth startups to scale and fundraise, directly and through his involvement with leading innovation organizations including Harvard Business School, Harvard Innovation Labs, and the MIT Enterprise Forum. He is also the author of “The Evergreen Startup,” a popular book on early-stage startup fundraising. He holds multiple patents and has received several awards for his work, including the Edison Universe Edison Award, the TIME Magazine Best Inventions Award, The Business Journals Top Inventor Award, Brandeis University Alumni Entrepreneur Award, and the TechCrunch Disrupt Wildcard Award.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

You May Also Like
Credit: Shutterstock

Immigrant entrepreneurs created ChatGPT. Is AI a superior alternative to our flawed systems or a dystopian hellscape?

Artificial intelligence (AI) recently entered the long list of epoch-making technological innovations credited to the hard work of immigrant founders. ChatGTP, which was developed by Open AI, a company that was launched by an international team, has been making headlines over the past few months. Mike Burtov, a star entrepreneur and mentor, is wondering whether AI will usher in a glorious future for humanity or could prove to be a ticking time bomb.
Credit: Shutterstock

Revisit the Pivot: How international startups can “make lemonade” out of their failures in America

Many tech companies are moving to the U.S. after enjoying success in their local European, Asian, or LatAm markets. But the American reality turns out to be different than expected. Products, approaches, and sometimes business concepts that worked well at home often fail in the U.S. After pouring resources into the world’s most competitive market, many leave disappointed. But there’s a way for them to change this. Star entrepreneur Mike Burtov, who has helped multiple startups grow, recommends immigrant founders to “make lemonade out of lemons” and embrace the pivot.
Clubhouse co-founder Rohan Seth. Credit: Rohan Seth/Twitter

How Indian American Clubhouse co-founder Rohan Seth started a global audio revolution

Launched in April 2020, the audio-only app Clubhouse now has more than 10 million weekly active users around the world. Its success has led to Twitter introducing Spaces, Spotify launching Greenroom, and Facebook announcing live audio rooms. Despite the Clubhouse boom, few users are aware that one of the app’s co-founders, Rohan Seth, was born in India and raised in its capital city, Delhi.